Back to Transfusion Evidence Alert and Round-Up

Assessing unintentional creation of bias against men who have sex with men as a function of exposure to blood donor screening questionnaire: A national randomized controlled trial

Department of Psychiatry, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada. Department of Psychology, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada. Department of Epidemiology & Surveillance, Canadian Blood Services, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.

Transfusion. 2022
Full text from:

Other resources

PICO Summary

Population

Blood donors registered in the Canadian Blood Services (n= 903).

Intervention

Modified donor questionnaire that repositioned the men who have sex with men (MSM) question among neutral questions (n= 457).

Comparison

Existing blood donor eligibility questionnaire (n= 446).

Outcome

Participants who completed the existing donor eligibility questionnaire more strongly associated gay men with negative attributes on the sexuality implicit association test (IAT), suggesting question position generated implicit negative bias toward MSM. Responses to the Modern Homonegativity Scale - Gay Men (MHS-G) and prevalence estimation task indicated that question order had no significant impact on explicit bias.
Abstract
BACKGROUND Canadian Blood Services (CBS) screens donors based on group status (e.g., men who have sex with men, MSM) instead of specific, high-risk sexual practices (e.g., occurrence of condomless sex). The MSM screening question is embedded in a cluster of questions about stigmatized attributes such as history of imprisonment and illicit substance use. This juxtaposition of the "MSM question" and stigmatized attributes may unintentionally cause blood donors to perceive MSM more negatively. The aim of this research is to determine whether the CBS donor eligibility questionnaire generates negative bias against MSM. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS A national, randomized online study of 903 CBS donors was conducted. Participants completed either the existing blood donor eligibility questionnaire or a modified donor questionnaire that repositioned the MSM question among neutral questions. After completing the existing or modified questionnaire, bias against MSM was measured using the sexuality implicit association test (IAT) and Modern Homonegativity Scale - Gay Men (MHS-G). Lastly, participants estimated prevalence rates among MSM of certain stigmatized behaviors. RESULTS Participants who completed the existing donor eligibility questionnaire more strongly associated gay men with negative attributes on the IAT (p(one-tailed) = .045), suggesting question position generated implicit negative bias toward MSM. Responses to the MHS-G (p(one-tailed) = .506) and prevalence estimation task (p = .443) indicated that question order had no significant impact on explicit bias. DISCUSSION Positioning the MSM screening question among stigmatizing questions creates implicit negative bias against MSM. Policy makers should be mindful of question positioning when designing donor questionnaires.
Study details
Language : eng
Credits : Bibliographic data from MEDLINE®/PubMed®, a database of the U.S. National Library of Medicine